Labour, Discipline and the “New Soviet Person”: Pedagogy, Labour Communes and the Reformatory in Turkestan’s Institutions for Neglected Adolescents
Keywords:
labour communes; reformatory; juvenile delinquency; Soviet pedagogy; Turkestan; vocational training; collective education; MakarenkoAbstract
The rehabilitation of neglected and delinquent adolescents in early Soviet Turkestan rested on a single organising idea: that productive labour, combined with collective life, would re-socialise young people damaged by war, famine and the street. This article analyses how that idea was translated into institutions—labour communes, labour colonies, factory-training schools (FZU) and, uniquely in Turkestan, a reformatory—and into the teaching and upbringing practised in orphanages and communes. It places the Turkestan material in the all-Union conceptual frame (the “Unified Labour School”, the writings of Poznyshev, Vasilevsky and Kufaev, and the example of Makarenko) and compares it with evidence from Kazakhstan and with Anglophone scholarship on the ideological aims of Soviet child institutions. The article argues that the Turkestan system formed a graduated “corridor of socialisation” from orphanage to workshop, with the reformatory and the labour communes serving as two alternative responses—isolation and control on one side, socialisation through work on the other—to the same problem. It also argues that the system’s effectiveness was limited by shortages of money and qualified staff, by the tension between education and production, by the weak integration of the region’s linguistic and cultural diversity, and by the uncontrolled operation of collective self-government. Where the evidence dates from after 1924, this is stated.
References
1.Ball, A. (1994). And Now My Soul Is Hardened: Abandoned Children in Soviet Russia, 1918–1930. Berkeley: University of California Press.
2.Ball, A. (1993). State children: Soviet Russia’s bezprizornye and the new socialist generation. The Russian Review, 52(2), 228–247.
3.Usmanov, F. (2026). O‘zbekistonda bolalar qarovsizligini bartaraf etishda bolalar uylarining ahamiyati. Ўтмишга назар / Взгляд в прошлое / Look to the Past, 9(4/2), 53–59. (In Uzbek). See also Usmanov, F. A. (2022). Ўзбекистонда болалар қаровсизлиги масаласи (1917–1945 йиллар) (PhD dissertation abstract). Termez. (In Uzbek)
4.Khuzhanova, M. F. (2016). Istoriya detskikh domov v Uzbekistane: formirovanie, deyatelnost i problemy (1920–1930 gg.) [History of orphanages in Uzbekistan]. Molodoi uchenyi, 19(123), 284–288. (In Russian)
5.Usmanov, F. A. (2026). Child homelessness and neglect in the Uzbek SSR in the second half of the 1920s. International Multidisciplinary Science Conference, 1(5), 171–176.
6.Savelyev, A. N., & Kostina, E. Yu. (n.d.). Problema detskoi besprizornosti v SSSR v 20–30 gody [The problem of child homelessness in the USSR in the 1920s–1930s]. Nauchnye issledovaniya i razrabotki molodykh uchenykh, 114–116. (In Russian)
7.Saktaganova, Z. G., & Karsakova, G. B. (2017). Vliyanie goloda na rost chisla besprizornykh detei v Akmolinskoi gubernii v 1920-e gg. Vestnik KazNU, Seriya istoricheskaya, 3(86), 5–9. (In Russian)
8.Kaipbaeva, A. T., Kozybaeva, M. M., Mukhatova, O. Kh., Baizhumanova, Z. B., & Bekenova, A. A. (Comps.). (2025). Iz istorii borby s detskoi besprizornostyu v Kazakhstane i sopredelnykh stranakh v 1920–1930-e gg. Almaty: Balausa. (In Russian)
9.Maslova, O. B. (2010). Likvidatsiya massovoi detskoi besprizornosti v Sovetskoi Rossii v 1920-e gody (Candidate’s dissertation abstract). Pyatigorsk. (In Russian)
10.Directives of the VKP(b) and decrees of the Soviet government on public education (1917–1947). (1947). Moscow: Literatura, p. 228. (In Russian); Savelyev & Kostina (n.d.), as in item 6.
11.Poznyshev, S. V. (1926). Detskaya besprizornost i mery borby s nei [Child homelessness and measures to combat it]. Moscow. (In Russian)
12.Vasilevsky, L. M. (1924). Golgofa rebenka: Besprizornost i deti ulitsy [The Golgotha of the child]. Leningrad–Moscow: Kniga. (In Russian)
13.Kufaev, V. I. (1924). Borba s pravonarusheniyami nesovershennoletnikh [The struggle against juvenile offences]. Moscow: Novaya Moskva, pp. 45–48. (In Russian)
14.Lyublinsky, P. I., & Kopelyanskaya, S. E. (1924). Okhrana detstva i borba s besprizornostyu. Leningrad: Academia. (In Russian)
15.Hillig, G. (1984). Svyatoi Makarenko: k izdaniyu proizvedenii A. S. Makarenko Akademiei pedagogicheskikh nauk RSFSR/SSSR (1950–1983 gg.) [Saint Makarenko: on the publication of A. S. Makarenko’s works]. Moscow, pp. 12–15. (In Russian)
16.NAU, f. R-94, op. 5, d. 1719, l. 14.
17.NAU, f. R-837, op. 13, d. 43, ll. 24–25.
18.NAU, f. R-86, op. 10, d. 1109, l. 47.
19.Usmanov (2026), as in item 3; see also Khuzhanova (2016).
20.NAU, f. R-94, op. 5, d. 3133, ll. 3, 24–25.
21.NAU, f. R-837, op. 6, d. 6, l. 44.
22.NAU, f. R-94, op. 5, d. 2111, l. 3.
23.Archival data as summarised in the author’s doctoral research; document references to be specified.
24.Slavko, A. A. (2011). Detskaya besprizornost i beznadzornost v Rossii kontsa 1920-kh – nachala 1950-kh godov (Doctoral dissertation abstract). Samara. (In Russian)
Austria
Uzbekistan
United States
United Kingdom
Germany
France
Italy
Spain
Turkey
Saudi Arabia
United Arab Emirates
Qatar
Egypt
Jordan
India
Pakistan
Bangladesh
China
Japan
South Korea
Malaysia
Indonesia
Kazakhstan
Kyrgyzstan
Tajikistan